Peer-Review Process
At Lingkar: Journal of Environmental Engineering, we uphold the integrity of science through a rigorous double-blind peer-review system. Each submission undergoes a thorough evaluation by at least two anonymous reviewers to ensure the content's validity, quality, and originality.
Key Features of Our Review Process:
-
Double-Blind Review: Per our commitment to objectivity, authors and reviewers remain anonymous throughout the review process until articles are approved for subsequent stages and publication.
-
Evaluation Criteria: Articles are meticulously evaluated based on the following:
- Originality of scientific work.
- Relevance between methodology and research topic.
- Comprehensive analysis.
- Clarity in communication with readers.
- Feedback and recommendations from reviewers.
-
Review Duration: Typically, the screening and evaluation process for manuscripts spans four to six months from the date of receipt.
-
Language Policy: We welcome submissions in both Indonesian and English, catering to a diverse readership.
-
Decision Authority: The journal reserves the right to determine the acceptance or rejection of any submitted article.
Peer review is instrumental in ensuring the quality and credibility of academic content. By filtering out substandard articles, we maintain the sanctity of our journal's brand and add value to the approved manuscripts. Our commitment lies in guaranteeing a robust peer-review system for every article that graces our journal.
The OJS Editorial and Publishing Process is described in the picture below
