The Effect of Rejection of Itsbat Nikah on Inheritance (Study of Judges' Legal Considerations Number: 124/Pdt.G/2023/MS.Bna): Pengaruh Penolakan Itsbat Nikah Pada Kewarisan (Studi Terhadap Pertimbangan Hukum Hakim Nomor: 124/Pdt.G/2023/MS.Bna)

Siti Najla; Ali Abubakar; Yenny Sri Wahyuni

doi:10.22373/hadhanah.v4i2.5976

Authors

Siti Najla Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh
Ali Abubakar Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-raniry Banda Aceh
Yenny Sri Wahyuni Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-raniry Banda Aceh

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.22373/hadhanah.v4i2.5976

Keywords:

Judges' Legal Considerations, Itsbat Nikah, Inheritance, Substantive Justice

Abstract

This research aims to explain judges' legal considerations from the perspective of procedural and substantive justice. This is because the decision 124/Pdt.G/2023/MS.Bna, which was a case where the application for a marriage registration was rejected and caused problems with the purpose of the marriage ceremony, thus affecting the position of the parties before and after the decision. In this research the author used qualitative research methods and a normative juridical approach, namely by examining the judge's decisions (content analysis). The judge's legal considerations are analyzed using the theory of justice (procedural and substantive) and compared with several other decisions. The results of the research show that the decision of the Banda Aceh Syar'iyah Court which was based on the provisions of the Compilation of Islamic Law resulted in everyone having the right to become heirs except the applicant, whereas if it was based on the provisions of fiqh the applicant had the right to become an heir because the applicant's marriage was valid in harmony and according to the requirements of Islamic law. . In considering decision 124/Pdt.G/2023/MS.Bna the judge sided with the nature of procedural justice only and ignored substantive justice, resulting in formal justice which was only guided by the law. If the judge uses extra-legal considerations and substantive justice, the itsbat application is very worthy of being accepted.

References

Abubakar, Rifa’i, Pengantar Metodologi Penelitian (SUKA-Press UIN Sunan Kalijaga, 2020)

Adami, Muhammad, ‘ISBAT NIKAH : Perkawinan Sirri Dan Pembagian Harta Bersama’, AT-TAFAHUM: Journal of Islamic Law, 1.2 (2017)

Aini, Merliyana Kholillah, ‘Permohonan Itsbat Nikah Dalam Mendapatkan Hak Waris’ (Bandar Lampung, Universitas Lampung, 2023)

Amien, Mawardi, Kepastian Hukum “Itsbat Nikah” Terhadap Status Perkawinan, Status Anak Dan Status Harta Perkawinan (Kota Jakarta Pusat: Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan dan Pendidikan dan Pelatihan Hukum dan Peradilan - Mahkamah Agung Republik Indonesia., 2012)

Annisa, Nur Fitra, ‘Peranan Hakim Sebagai Penegak Hukum Berdasarkan Undung-Undang Nomor 48 Tahun 2009 Tentang Kekuasaan Kehakiman’, Lex et Societatis, V.3 (2017)

Assy’ra, Faisal Faisal, Fauzah Nur Aksa, and Dara Quthni Effida, ‘Itsbat Nikah Dan Akibat Hukumnya (Studi Penelitian Di Kota Lhokseumawe)’, Ius Civile: Refleksi Penegakan Hukum Dan Keadilan, 5.1 (2021)

Bafadhal, Faizah, ‘Itsbat Nikah Dan Implikasinya Terhadap Status Perkawinan Menurut Peraturan Perundang-Undangan Indonesia’, Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 5.1 (2014)

Bawono, Royan, and Rita Khairani, ‘Analisis Hukum Tentang Isbat Nikah Menurut KUH Perdata Dan KHI Indonesia’, Lentera: Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Islamic Studies, 4.2 (2022)

Camelia, ‘Anjing Ini Dapat Warisan Rp 69 Miliar Dari Pemiliknya Yang Meninggal’, Liputan6.Com, 2021 <https://www.liputan6.com/citizen6/read/4483230/anjing-ini-dapat-warisan-rp-69-miliar-dari-pemiliknya-yang-meninggal> [accessed 28 October 2024]

Diab, Ashadi L., ‘Legalisasi Nikah Siri Melalui Isbat Nikah Perspektif Fikih (Telaah Terhadap Kompilasi Hukum Islam)’, Jurnal Al-’Adl, 2.3 (2018)

Djawas, Mursyid, Fikih Faraidh Teknik Penyelesaian Kasus Waris (Aceh: Sahifah, 2020)

Efendi, Jonaedi, Rekonstruksi Dasar Pertimbangan Hukum Hakim Berbasis Nilai-Nilai Hukum Dan Rasa Keadilan Yang Hidup Dalam Masyarakat, Prenadamedia Group (Depok: PRENADAMEDIA GROUP, 2018)

Faizah, Isniyatin, Febiyanti Utami Parera, and Silvana Kamelya, ‘Bagian Ahli Waris Laki-Laki Dan Perempuan Dalam Kajian Hukum Islam’, The Indonesian Journal of Islamic Law and Civil Law, 2.2 (2021)

Fathia, Rizky Amelia, and Dian Septiandani, ‘Dampak Penolakan Itsbat Nikah Terhadap Pemenuhan Hak Anak’, Jurnal Usm Law Review, 5.2 (2022)

Fauzi, Ahmad, ‘Isbat Nikah Solusi Bagi Nikah Siri’, Jurnal Sosial Sains, 1.9 (2021)

Haryono, ‘PENEGAKAN HUKUM BERBASIS NILAI KEADILAN SUBSTANTIF (Studi Putusan MK No. 46/PUU-VII/2012 Tertanggal 13 Februari 2012)’, Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 7.1 (2019)

Hilmiati, Arfi, and Kartika Yusrina, ‘Dampak Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi NO. 46/PUUVIII/2010 Terhadap Hukum Perkawinan Di Indonesia’, MAWADDAH: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Islam, 1.1 (2023)

Kartina, Ratu Mawar, ‘Akibat Hukum Terhadap Harta Kekayaan Yang Ditimbulkan Dari Perkawinan Siri Menurut Kompilasi Hukum Islam’, Syntax Idea, 1.6 (2019)

M. Yunus, Fakhrurrazi, and Dwi Oktavia, ‘Perlindungan Hak Anak Pra Isbat Nikah Ditinjau Dari Hukum Positif (Studi Kasus Putusan Mahkamah Syar’iyah Nomor 40/Pdt.P/2021/MS.Bna)’, Jurnal El-Hadhanah : Indonesian Journal Of Family Law And Islamic Law, 3.1 (2023)

Mardiyah, Aenatul, ‘Akibat Hukum Penolakan Itsbat Nikah Terhadap Hak Keperdataan Anak (Studi Putusan Nomor 0468/PDT.G/2018/PA.Srg)’, SYAHKSIA Jurnal Hukum Perdata Islam, 20.1 (2019)

Merdeka, ‘Cerita Lengkap TKW Indonesia Dapat Warisan Rp1 M Dari Aktor Taiwan Chen Sung Young’, Merdeka.Com, 2022 <https://www.merdeka.com/trending/jadi-milyader-dadakan-tkw-indonesia-dapat-warisan-dari-aktor-taiwan-chen-sung-young.html> [accessed 28 October 2024]

Muhaimin, Metode Penelitian Hukum (Mataram-NTB: Mataram University Press, 2020)

Najmuddin, M. Naufal, and Adi Laksono, ‘Kedudukan Hak Waris Istri Siri Beserta Anaknya Menurut Hukum Waris Islam’, Justicia Journal, 10.2 (2021)

Nasution, Bahder Johan, ‘Kajian Filosofis Tentang Konsep Keadilan Dari Pemikiran Klasik Sampai Pemikiran Modern’, Yustisia, 3.2 (2014)

Pispita, Shintiya Dwi, and Fabian Fadhly, ‘Legitieme Portie Dalam Hukum Waris Islam Di Indonesia’, Veritas et Justitia ; Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 1.2 (2015)

Rahmad, Noor, and Wildan Hafis, ‘Hukum Progresif Dan Relevansinya Pada Penalaran Hukum Di Indonesia’, El-Ahli : Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Islam, 1.2 (2021)

Riewanto, Agus, Andy Omara, Eka NAM Sihombing, Isnawati, Jamaludin Ghafur, Jimmy Z. Usfunan, and others, Hukum Tata Negara (Depok: PT RAJAGRAFINDO PERSADA, 2023)

Riyanto, Agus, ‘Pengaruh Positivisme Terhadap Penegakan Hukum’, BUSINESS LAW, 2018 <https://business-law.binus.ac.id/2018/12/26/pengaruh-positivisme-terhadap-penegakan-hukum/> [accessed 27 October 2024]

Sarwani, Novita, ‘Efektivitas Pelaksanaan Sidang Keliling Dalam Perkara Isbat Nikah (Studi Kasus Pada Mahkamah Syar’iyah Takengon Kelas IB)’, Jurnal El-Hadhanah: Indonesian Journal of Family Law and Islamic Law, 2.2 (2022)

Umar, Abu, Faruq Ahmad, Mohammad Ashraful Mobin, Ali Abubakar, Bismi Khalidin, Iskandar Usman, and others, ‘Kewarisan Antarumat Beragama Versus Kewajiban Nafkah’, MEDIA SYARI’AH Wahana Kajian Hukum Islam Pranata Sosial, 19.1 (2017)

Yunanto, ‘Menerjemahkan Keadilan Dalam Putusan Hakim’, Jurnal Hukum Progresif, 7.2 (2019)